Buying Advice

5-Year Cost to Own: The Accord Hybrid Beats the Cheaper K5 and Altima by Up to $7,300

We priced five midsize sedans on sticker, fuel, insurance, and resale. The Accord Hybrid costs the most up front and the least to own; the K5 is the reverse.

Honda Accord, Toyota Camry, Hyundai Sonata, Kia K5 and Nissan Altima sedans
Five midsize sedans, five-year ownership costs from $29,750 to $37,035 at 15,000 miles a year. Photo: Honda / Toyota / Hyundai / Kia / Nissan

The cheapest midsize sedan on a dealer's lot is not the cheapest one to own. We priced five of them, the Honda Accord Hybrid Sport, Toyota Camry SE, Hyundai Sonata Hybrid SEL, Kia K5 GT-Line, and Nissan Altima SV, on sticker, fuel, insurance, and resale over five years. The Accord costs the most to buy and the least to keep. The K5 and Altima are the reverse.

At 15,000 miles a year, the gap between the cheapest and the most expensive car to own is about $7,300, or roughly $120 a month. That is a bigger number than the spread in sticker prices, and it runs in the opposite direction. Our Camry vs. Accord Hybrid cost-to-own comparison covered the two best sellers in detail; this guide adds the three cheaper alternatives and resale.

How we did the math

Prices are manufacturer MSRPs plus destination for the trim each brand sells at the heart of its range: the 2026 Accord Hybrid Sport (Honda has not announced a 2027 Accord for the U.S.), and the 2027 Camry SE, Sonata Hybrid SEL, K5 GT-Line, and Altima SV, all with front-wheel drive. Fuel uses EPA combined ratings from fueleconomy.gov and AAA's national average for regular on Nov. 15, $3.82 a gallon. We did not project gas prices.

Insurance is Insurify's average full-coverage quote for each model, as listed on Nov. 13. Depreciation applies each model's five-year value loss from iSeeCars' resale-value study to today's price. Financing, taxes, registration, maintenance, and repairs are left out, because they vary more by buyer and state than by car. The structure follows the one we used for RAV4 Hybrid vs. Plug-in vs. bZ five-year costs.

Five-year cost to own, side by side

CriteriaHonda Accord Hybrid Sport (2026)Toyota Camry SE FWD (2027)Hyundai Sonata Hybrid SEL (2027)Kia K5 GT-Line FWD (2027)Nissan Altima SV FWD (2027)
Price with destination$34,990 ($33,795 + $1,195)$33,495 ($32,200 + $1,295)$33,945 ($32,700 + $1,245*)$29,935 ($28,690 + $1,245)$29,065 ($27,790 + $1,275)
Powertrain2.0L hybrid, 204 hp2.5L hybrid, 225 hp2.0L hybrid, 192 hp2.5L gas, 191 hp2.5L gas, 188 hp
EPA combined44 mpg46 mpg47 mpg29 mpg30 mpg
Fuel, 5 years at 15,000 mi/yr$6,518$6,235$6,102$9,890$9,560
Insurance, 5 years (Insurify average per year)$12,070 ($2,414)$12,150 ($2,430)$12,570 ($2,514)$15,710 ($3,142)$12,910 ($2,582)
Depreciation, 5 years (iSeeCars rate)$11,162 (31.9%)$12,360 (36.9%)$14,834 (43.7%)$11,435 (38.2%)$13,021 (44.8%)
Powertrain warranty5 yr/60,000 mi5 yr/60,000 mi; 2 yr/25,000 mi maintenance included10 yr/100,000 mi10 yr/100,000 mi5 yr/60,000 mi
Total, 5 years at 15,000 mi/yr$29,750 ($496/mo)$30,744 ($512/mo)$33,506 ($558/mo)$37,035 ($617/mo)$35,491 ($592/mo)
Total, 5 years at 8,000 mi/yr$26,708 ($445/mo)$27,835 ($464/mo)$30,658 ($511/mo)$32,420 ($540/mo)$31,030 ($517/mo)

*Hyundai lists the 2027 Sonata Hybrid SEL at $32,700 but does not show a 2027 freight charge on its site; we used the 2026 figure. Totals exclude financing, taxes, fees, maintenance, and repairs. Depreciation is the same in both mileage scenarios, although a car driven 75,000 miles will usually be worth less than one driven 40,000.

Where the money actually goes

Fuel is the line everyone looks at first, and it matters: over five years at 15,000 miles a year, the three hybrids burn $6,100 to $6,500 of gasoline, while the K5 and Altima burn $9,560 to $9,890. That is a gap of up to $3,800. Each 50-cent move in the price of a gallon shifts a gas car's yearly bill by about $250 and a hybrid's by $160 to $170, so the order in the table holds across any realistic range of pump prices.

But fuel is not the biggest swing. The Sonata Hybrid has the best EPA rating here, 47 mpg, and still finishes $2,760 behind the Camry because it loses about $2,470 more in value. The K5 holds its value better than the Altima, yet its average insurance quote, $3,142 a year, is $728 higher than the Accord's and adds $3,640 over five years. Insurance and resale each move the totals as much as gasoline does.

Depreciation also explains why buying slightly used can beat all five of these totals: the first owner absorbs the steepest part of the curve. If that is your plan, our look at the best time to buy a used car, per iSeeCars covers when prices typically dip.

Cheaper to buy is not cheaper to own

The Altima SV is $5,925 cheaper than the Accord Hybrid Sport with destination. Over five years at 15,000 miles a year, it costs $5,741 more to own. The Altima spends $3,042 more on gas, loses $1,859 more in value, and costs $840 more to insure. The Accord's higher sticker comes back at trade-in: on these rates it is worth about $23,800 after five years, against about $16,000 for the Altima.

The sticker still matters for one kind of buyer: someone financing to a monthly payment. On a 60-month loan at 7 percent, the $5,925 difference is about $117 a month, and that money is paid now, while the Accord's advantage arrives at resale.

If you are willing to step down a size, the same logic applies to compacts, as our comparison of Corolla Hybrid, Elantra Hybrid, Civic Hybrid, and Prius shows.

What we don't know

  • What you will actually pay. Dealer discounts and factory incentives change monthly and by region, and none are included here.
  • Resale for these exact cars. iSeeCars measures each nameplate across all versions, using five-year-old models; hybrid-only resale data for the current Camry and Accord does not exist yet. Kelley Blue Book's own forecast for a 2026 Accord Hybrid Sport is harsher, at $15,859 of depreciation over five years.
  • Your insurance rate. Insurify's averages are national; your age, record, and ZIP code matter more than the model.
  • The Altima's future. Nissan disputed a July WardsAuto report that the car was ending and put a 2027 model on sale, but it has said nothing about 2028. A discontinued model can lose value faster.
  • The Accord's next step. Motor1 reports a redesigned Accord could arrive in the second half of 2027 as a 2028 model; Honda has not confirmed it.

For the full list of costs this table leaves out, from registration to tires, see our breakdown of AAA's 2026 driving-cost figures.

Which one should you buy

If you drive 15,000 miles a year: the Accord Hybrid Sport is the cheapest car here to own, at about $496 a month. The Camry SE is $994 behind over five years, or about $17 a month, and offers all-wheel drive for $1,525 plus two years of included maintenance; either is a sound pick. The Sonata Hybrid is efficient but carries the weakest resale of the three hybrids.

If you drive 8,000 miles a year: the hybrids' lead narrows but does not disappear. The Accord and Camry still finish first and second, the Sonata Hybrid and Altima are within $400 of each other, and the K5 remains last because of insurance.

If the monthly payment is the hard limit: the Altima SV and K5 GT-Line are the lowest stickers, and the K5 adds a 10-year powertrain warranty. Get insurance quotes before signing, because on the averages the K5 gives back most of its price advantage. For everyone else, paying more for a hybrid sedan is the cheaper decision.